In one corner, we have “Ridiculously Photogenic Guy” Zeddie Little, who recently become an internet sensation thanks to his ability to be, uh, ridiculously photogenic. While jogging in South Carolina’s 2012 Cooper River Bridge Run, his photo was taken by a bystander and turned into an incredibly popular web meme, prompting everyone to Facebook stalk him.

In the other, we have Old Spice guy Isaiah Mustafa, who’s rippling pectoral region was the eye candy to so many women before the insanely chiseled Terry Crews came along.

Mustafa beat out Fabio back in the day, and became a viral hit on his own through his sexi-fied commercials as the ultimate ladies man.

So, which one is more attractive? It’s now time for you to decide in our poll below.